Wednesday, October 8, 2008

DOUBLE JEOPARDY: HANDICAPPING THE HANDICAPPED

She was not born mute. She could sing. She could laugh. She could talk. She was a normal child with a cheerful spirit and a good disposition. Until misfortune struck which left her deaf in both ears. That didn’t stop Emilie Padullon from chasing her dreams though. She went through a great deal of trials, each step a traumatic episode in unlearning spoken words which were slowly eaten away by silence. Since there was no way she could hear even faint utterances, the notion of sound – and strangely, the ability to speak – departed from her. Then when she was of age, she herself enrolled at the Manila Christian Computer Institute for the Deaf (MCCID).

As soon as Emilie graduated from the institute in 1996, she instinctively wanted to work. With the assistance of the MCCID Training Director, Jojo Esposa, Jr. whose mission in life centered on helping the deaf and mute, she e-mailed all the Philippine senators seeking employment assistance. Only then-senator Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo replied to her and the rest is history. Todate, Emilie has been working for the now-president Arroyo for more than a decade.

But such cases are rare in the professional world where communication skills rank high among qualifications of prospective employees.

Raymond Cuevas, an accountancy graduate of the College of St. Benilde is not as lucky. Now 38, he has been constantly searching for clerical jobs since his graduation and is now almost at the end of his rope. He has been to Malacañang twice and as he told us through an interpreter, it wasn’t a pleasant experience when doors close in front of your face.

Likewise, Sharon Rivera, a 28-year-old blind masseuse at the Visually Impaired Brotherhood for Excellent Service (VIBES) Health Spa in Tugatog, Malabon supports her family by means of the commission she receives from her job. Her blindness prevented her from pursuing a college degree even if, because of her academic excellence, she had been promoted from fourth grade in her elementary years to being a sophomore year in high school.

The plights of persons with disability, their constant rejection and dejection, remain to be edged out of focus in a world fast becoming technologically savvy but compassionately inadequate.

True, the government has done more than its modest share of responsibility. In March of 1992, Congress has approved Republic Act No. 7277, otherwise known as the Magna Carta for Disabled Persons. In it, the rights and privileges of the disabled have been clearly outlined.

Among others, the State ensures that our physically-challenged countrymen are provided access to quality education and ample opportunities to develop their skills. The State is also to protect and promote the right to health of disabled persons and adopt an integrated and comprehensive approach to their health development which shall make essential health services available to them at affordable cost. As far as auxiliary services are concerned, the State is to provide these marginalized persons with the necessary services that will restore their social functioning and participation in community affairs. In the field of telecommunications, one of the provisions is for television stations to provide a sign-language inset or subtitles in at least one newscast program a day and special programs covering events of national significance. For the disabled to gain access to public and private buildings and establishments, the State is to ensure the attainment of a barrier-free environment. More importantly, the State provides that the physically-handicapped are not to be denied access to opportunities for suitable employment and that no entity, whether public or private, shall discriminate against a qualified disabled person by reason of disability in regard to job application procedures, the hiring, promotion, or discharge of employees, employee compensation, job training, and other terms, conditions, and privileges of employment.

But such government posturing needs careful scrutiny. The current state of the matter leaves a lot to be desired.

Beth Ancheta, a music professor for the blind at the Philippine Women’s University, sings another tune.

“Unlike in other countries where the disabled are in communities where their own kind is taken care of,” she said, “only a few are being addressed here.”

Ancheta who has been teaching blind artistically-inclined students during the last 17 years, has carved a soft spot in her heart for these handicapped artists.

“We do not treat them any differently in school. In fact, even if the handicapped has the tendency to think of themselves as ‘special’, we do not tolerate such behavior. We encourage them to help themselves.” She laments, however, that the arts is not well-supported by the government.

Ancheta is also an active member of a church group that ministers to the deaf and mute. She provides sign-language translation for the deaf-mute parishioners at the Day By Day Christian Ministries – an evangelical church located at the Folk Arts Theater – during Sunday worship services. In the church, where she learned and mastered sign-language, she gets involved in other social activities that help the disabled.

“We have the law, but the implementation is insufficient,” she gripes. “For example, we do not have enough sign-language experts in the courts and even in hospitals. We heard of an inmate at the Pasay City jail, who has not been arraigned yet because they do not have an interpreter.” (A call to the Pasay City jail to confirm this statement was made. The jail, however, does not have a record of a disabled inmate.)

Another supporter of the disabled, Dr. King Cedeño of the Ospital ng Makati, confirms what Ancheta said. “We only depend on the relatives of the disabled for communicating their ailments when they are brought to the hospital because generally, the hospitals do not have sign-language experts in their employ.”

When asked if he thinks the government is doing enough to help alleviate the lives of the disabled, he echoes Ancheta’s sentiment. “It is in the implementation of the law where we sorely lack government monitoring.” He cites that even large television networks do not even provide sign-language insets for the deaf and mute. “How can we expect them to participate in national quorum when they are not aware of what is going on around them?”

As recent as April 2007, the Magna Carta was amended by Republic Act 9442 which provides incentives in the form of 20% discounts for lodging, entertainment, medical, and transportation services. And in perhaps a monumental move to soften the stigma of their physical condition, the title of the Magna Carta has been amended from “Magna Carta for Disabled Persons” to “Magna Carta for Persons with Disability”. Which politically-corrects their status: they are not disabled, they have disability.

A National Statistics Office census released in March 2005 announced that 1.23 per cent of the approximately 80 million Filipinos are persons with disability, a staggering 942,098 individuals. It is of no small significance that the lawmakers in this country must leave no stones unturned in filing bills that are to be beneficial to the handicapped members of our society. Yet, for all of the bills filed and laws passed by Congress benefiting our disabled countrymen, the public perception that there is not enough being done by the State remains high.

While it is commendable that the government is using its arms to improve the social benefits of the persons with disability, the more important issue that remains a source of instability for the disabled is that which concerns employment. For how can the handicapped people enjoy the social benefits bestowed on them when they do not have the job, and consequently the means, to partake of them?

For its part, the government is not lacking in its intention to spearhead employment of persons with disability. In fact, in Republic Act 7277, it has specifically instructed that “five percent (5%) of all casual emergency and contractual positions in the Departments of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD); Health (DOH); Education, Culture and Sports (DECS); and other government agencies, offices or corporations engaged in social development shall be reserved for disabled persons.”

However, the National Council for the Welfare of the Disabled Persons (NCWDP), which under Executive Order No. 676 became directly under the Office of the President, provided us with the latest summary of government-employed persons with disabilities (PWD) as of 2006. It gives a dismal number of only 4,373 government-employed PWDs broken down as follows: 2,373 in national government agencies including soldiers; 202 in government owned and controlled corporations; 98 in state universities and colleges; 105 in government hospitals; and 1,595 in local government units.

Figures obtained from NCWPD as regards employment of PWDs in government departments particularly appointed to reserve slots for disabled persons also proved disappointing: DSWD – 0, DOH – 4 out of its 371 employees at BFAD, DECS – 8 out of its 1,716 employees. The NCWPD itself employs 8 PWDs out of its 57 workforce. Other government agencies which employ disabled persons are as follows: Labor – 33 out of 6,819; Science and Technology – 17; Statistics – 13 out of 3,599; DOJ – 8; Public Works – 8 out of 2,549; Light Railways – 3 out of 1,572; Agriculture – 7 out of 479; Foreign Affairs – 12 out of 2,240; SSS – 9 out of 3,996; National Power Corporation – 2; NEDA – 5.

Thankfully, the private sector offers more than its fair share of the responsibilities. Topmost in the list of enterprising private benefactors are the massage clinics in malls and city districts that provide employment for the blind. For every clinic that employs a minimum of 10 masseurs and masseuses, the economic lives of at least a few are helped in a big way.

Dante Tiosan, founder of VIBES disclosed that his disenchantment with the government’s non-effort to support entrepreneurship programs for the visually impaired led him to leave his post at the DSWD to spearhead a multi-purpose cooperative to help the blinds – like him – become their own bosses.

“The government is keen only on providing training. They provide budgets for this purpose, and it is not bad. But what is more important is to give the blinds the opportunity to have their own business,” he complained. “Along this line, the government is not keen on spending.”

He formed VIBES that now has a network of 335 massage therapists all over the country employed in 37 livelihood projects, of which 70% are owners of shares in the company. The therapists are paid on commission basis and enjoy the privileges offered by SSS and Pag-ibig.

“Fifteen of our members got their own houses through Pag-ibig,” he enthused. “It cannot be said now that the blinds are liabilities. The truth is we have several sighted persons in our employ that are dependent on the blinds.”

In the Magna Carta, provisions are stated that offer incentives to employers of persons with disability in the form of 25% deduction from the gross income for amounts paid in salaries and wages to the disabled and 50% deduction from the net taxable income for amounts used to improve physical facilities for the accommodation of disabled persons.

Asked if his company has benefited from this scheme, Dante said, “Yes, I am aware of such provisions, but the process is as tedious as going through the eye of the needle. Up to now, we have not taken advantage of these tax rebates because a lot of documentations are required both by the Department of Labor and Department of Health.”

Dante is not alone in his crusade. Ben Chan, of the famous Bench chains, has also given a steadfast support to the deaf and mute. He mandated Be Connected Management Service, a management service provider, to hire deaf-mute for their merchandising and sales teams.

“Kasama sila sa plantilla. There are slots explicitly allotted for the deaf and mute. Yun ang gusto ni Mr. Chan,” Edwin Rosales, the Recruitment Manager of Be Connected, explains. “We have more than 100 deaf and mute staff distributed in the various stores, warehouses, and factories of Bench.”

When asked to describe the working relations with the deaf-mute, Rosales excitedly narrates, “They are treated the same way as the rest of the crew. They are provided with similar trainings. But even non-deaf staff is given orientation in sign-language. They also receive the same disciplinary actions as the regular guys when warranted.”

However, because of the changing mood of business which needs fresh faces in merchandising every so often, Bench is constrained not to hire them – as well as the non-deaf ones – longer than five months. “This is also in line with being able to help as many disabled persons as we can by giving them opportunities to be employed even for a short while,” Rosales explains.

Still another company that extends more than an arm of support is Lamoiyan Corporation, maker of Hapee toothpaste. According to Daisy Gavales, a human resources staff, they have 30 regular deaf-and-mute employees in their factory line. These people have been working for the company for more than a decade. “On top of this,” she said, “we continue to hire ‘piece-raters’ and contractual helpers when we have seasonal requirements.”

At Lamoiyan, their disabled staff receives equal salaries as those of their non-deaf counterparts. “We do not discriminate and the interaction between the deaf and the non-deaf staff is cordial. We also give sign-language training in order for communication to be fluid among our factory workers.”

Asked if they ever applied for incentives in view of their hiring of disabled persons, “I do not recall having done anything like that,” Gavales answered. “It is enough that a lot of social and civic groups recognize what we are doing. The awards we received through the years are good enough incentives.”

Another commendable institution that provides ample training for the deaf and mute is the Manila Christian Computer Institute for the Deaf, who was instrumental in the placement of Emilie Padullon in President Arroyo’s employ. The institute continues to send trainees to various government and private offices. Two of their multi-awarded graduates – Aldrin Gabriel and Ronald Josef Santiago – are now employed as staff of Malabon City Mayor Canuto Oreta.

Considering the major efforts being pushed by the private sectors in accommodating persons with disabilities into its workforce, the government is now challenged to flex its muscles in giving room for employment to our disabled countrymen. In a country whose government contends and takes pride in economic growth – but where even the most physically-fit and soundly-educated Filipino finds difficulty in acquiring gainful and permanent employment – what chances are left to the physically-handicapped?

Ironically, it was a Philippine-led initiative composed by Filipino diplomats who pushed for the adoption of the resolution “Implementation of the World Program of Action Concerning Disabled Persons: Realizing the Millennium Development Goals for Persons with Disabilities” at the United Nations. As reported by the Philippine Daily Inquirer in January 2008, the resolution aims at including the perspective of persons with disabilities when they set targets to exert more effort toward addressing the problems of “inadequate incomes” among others.

The Philippine’s permanent representative to the United Nations, Ambassador Hilario Davide, Jr. lauded the adoption of the resolution as one that “underscores the importance the Philippines places on the issue of disability.”

If the employment of disabled persons in the venerable halls of the Philippine Congress is to be used as a measure of that importance, Davide may need to think again. The very halls manned by senators and congressmen who produce profound rhetoric in filing bills for uplifting the lives of the handicapped could not produce a significant number of disabled persons under their respective employ.

A survey conducted by these reporters revealed that in the Senate, only one (1) wheel-chaired person – in the Blue Ribbon Committee of Senator Alan Peter Cayetano - is employed by a combination of 23 senators. At the House of Representatives, only (2) persons with disability – in the offices of Congressmen Rex Gatchalian and Roger Mercado – are employed by a combination of 240 representatives. This does not include Congresswoman Ma. Victoria Sy-Alvarado, herself a polio victim.

In the Explanatory Note attached by Senator Eduardo Angara when he filed Senate Bill No. 1982 to amend Republic Act 7277, he explained that the bill “is not aimed to develop our attitudes of PWDs as charity cases but rather to empower PWDs to meet their basic needs of…income security…among others.”

Such bravado is lamentable. With large sums of money being exchanged allegedly among congressmen for what have been euphemistically and interchangeably termed as “gifts”, “bonus”, “bribes” (most notably during votes to impeach or not to impeach) and with skyrocketing project allowances and allocations for senators (even for those imprisoned ones), nothing can be more nobler than hiring a disabled staff or two – not necessarily out of necessity – but out of compassionate charity.

Otherwise, it can’t be far from the truth to conclude that the spirit of the law, as far as the disabled persons are concerned, does not reside in its very letters – and that more than anything else, the law is nothing more than an act of grandstanding and unabashed lip-service.

No comments: