Saturday, August 30, 2008

MOA ISSUE POST NO. 3 - MARAWI AND THE MOA



During the 2001 plebiscite, the cities of Marawi and Lamitan and the six towns in Lanao del Norte voted YES for the "expanded ARMM" along with the provinces of Maguindanao, Lanao del Sur, Tawi-twai, Sulu, Basilan and Shariff Kabunsuan.


The current Memorandum of Agreement on Ancestral Domain includes these areas that will form the core of the proposed area of governance now being referred to as BJE or Bangsamoro Juridical Entity.

The Lanao del Norte towns are Balo-i, Munai, Nunungan, Pantar, Tagoloan and Tangcal.

The areas for inclusion in the BJE, subject to plebiscites, are 735 villages that are mostly predominantly Moro and contiguous to the ARMM and 1,459 conflict-affected areas that are predominantly Moro as well but scattered outside the present ARMM.

The 735 villages fall under what both parties call Category A; the 1,459 villages as “special intervention areas” under Category B.


(photo courtesy of http://www.daylife.com/)

MOA ISSUE POST NO. 2 - ANCESTRAL DOMAIN

Michael Tan has an informative article on abbreviations and the MOA.

In his article, he mentioned that "strangely, there is no reference to Republic Act 8371 passed in 1997..."

One look at the MOA and I think, Michael overlooked the reference.

MOA ISSUE POST NO. 1 - FULL TEXT OF THE MOA

Many things have been seen on TV and heard on radio and read in the newspaper about the MOA and the MILF and peace in Mindanao. But to the commoner, what these may things are may not mean anything at all.

For better understanding of the issues involved in the controversial agreement, please see full text of the Memorandum of Agreement below.



IN THE NAME OF GOD
THE BENEFICENT, THE MERCIFUL

MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT ON THE ANCESTRAL DOMAIN ASPECT OF THE GRP-MILF TRIPOLI AGREEMENT ON PEACE OF 2001

The Government of the Republic of the Philippines (GRP) and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) herein referred to as the “Parties” to this Agreement,

TERMS OF REFERENCE

The Agreement for General Cessation of Hostilities dated July 18, 1997 Between the GRP and the MILF, and its Implementing Administrative and Operational Guidelines;
The General Framework of Agreement of Intent Between the GRP and the MILF dated August 27, 1998;

The Agreement on the General Framework for the Resumption of Peace Talks Between the GRP and the MILF dated March 24, 2001;

The Tripoli Agreement on Peace Between the GRP and the MILF dated June 22, 2001;

The Tripoli Agreement Between the GRP and the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF) dated December 23, 1976 and the Final Agreement on the Implementation of the 1976 Tripoli Agreement Between the GRP and the MNLF dated September 2, 1996;

Republic Act No. 6734, as amended by R.A. 9054, otherwise known as “An Act to Strengthen and Expand the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM)”;

ILO Convention No. 169, in correlation to the UN Declaration on the Rights of the Indigenous Peoples, and Republic Act No. 8371 otherwise known as the Indigenous Peoples Rights Act of 1997, the UN Charter, the UN Universal Declaration on Human Rights, International Humanitarian Law (IHL), and internationally recognized human rights instruments; and

Compact rights entrenchment emanating from the regime of dar-ul-mua’hada (or territory under compact) and dar-ul-sulh (or territory under peace agreement) that partakes the nature of a treaty device. For the purpose of this Agreement, a “treaty” is defined as any solemn agreement in writing that sets out understandings, obligations, and benefits for both parties which provides for a framework that elaborates the principles declared in the Agreement.

HAVE AGREED AND ACKNOWLEDGED AS FOLLOWS:

CONCEPTS AND PRINCIPLES

It is the birthright of all Moros and all Indigenous peoples of Mindanao to identify themselves and be accepted as “Bangsamoros”. The Bangsamoro people refers to those who are natives or original inhabitants of Mindanao and its adjacent islands including Palawan and the Sulu archipelago at the time of conquest or colonization and their descendants whether mixed or of full native blood. Spouses and their descendants are classified as Bangsamoro. The freedom of choice of the Indigenous people shall be respected.

It is essential to lay the foundation of the Bangsamoro homeland in order to address the Bangsamoro people’s humanitarian and economic needs as well as their political aspirations. Such territorial jurisdictions and geographic areas being the natural wealth and patrimony represent the social, cultural and political identity and pride of all the Bangsamoro people. Ownership of the homeland is vested exclusively in them by virtue of their prior rights of occupation that had inhered in them as sizeable bodies of people, delimited by their ancestors since time immemorial, and being the first politically organized dominant occupants.

Both Parties acknowledge that ancestral domain does not form part of the public domain but encompasses ancestral, communal, and customary lands, maritime, fluvial and alluvial domains as well as all natural resources therein that have inured or vested ancestral rights on the basis of native title. Ancestral domain and ancestral land refer to those held under claim of ownership, occupied or possessed, by themselves or through the ancestors of the Bangsamoro people, communally or individually since time immemorial continuously to the present, except when prevented by war, civil disturbance, force majeure, or other forms of possible usurpation or displacement by force, deceit, stealth, or as a consequence of government project or any other voluntary dealings entered into by the government and private individuals, corporate entities or institutions.

Both Parties acknowledge that the right to self-governance of the Bangsamoro people is rooted on ancestral territoriality exercised originally under the suzerain authority of their sultanates and the Pat a Pangampong ku Ranaw. The Moro sultanates were states or karajaan/kadatuan resembling a body politic endowed with all the elements of nation-state in the modern sense. As a domestic community distinct from the rest of the national communities, they have a definite historic homeland. They are the “First Nation” with defined territory and with a system of government having entered into treaties of amity and commerce with foreign nations. The Parties concede that the ultimate objective of entrenching the Bangsamoro homeland as a territorial space is to secure their identity and posterity, to protect their property rights and resources as well as to establish a system of governance suitable and acceptable to them as a distinct dominant people.

Both Parties affirm their commitment to mutually respect the right to one’s identity and the parity of esteem of everyone in the political community. The protection of civil rights and religious liberties of individuals underlie the basis of peace and justice of their totality of relationships.
Both Parties agree that the Bangsamoro Juridical Entity (BJE) shall have the authority and jurisdiction over the Ancestral Domain and Ancestral lands, including both alienable and non-alienable lands encompassed within their homeland and ancestral territory, as well as the delineation of ancestral domain/lands of the Bangsamoro people located therein.

Vested property rights upon the entrenchment of the BJE shall be recognized and respected subject to paragraph 9 of the strand on Resources.

TERRITORY

The Bangsamoro homeland and historic territory refer to the land mass as well as the maritime, terrestrial, fluvial and alluvial domains, and the aerial domain, the atmospheric space above it, embracing the Mindanao-Sulu-Palawan geographic region. However, delimitations are contained in the agreed Schedules (Categories).

Toward this end, the Parties enter into the following stipulations:
The GRP and MILF as the Parties to this Agreement commit themselves to the full and mutual implementation of this framework agreement on territory with the aim of resolving outstanding issues that emanate from the consensus points on Ancestral Domain.

The Parties confirm their understanding that the mutual goal of reaching an agreement on Bangsamoro territory specific to mapping the outlying borders and the boundaries affecting local government units will lead to consolidation of the agreed texts on the Ancestral Domain Strands.

The Parties affirm that the core of the BJE shall constitute the present geographic area of the ARMM, including the municipalities of Baloi, Munai, Nunungan, Pantar, Tagoloan and Tangkal in the province of Lanao del Norte that voted for inclusion in the ARMM during the 2001 plebiscite.

Without derogating from the requirements of prior agreements, the Government stipulates to conduct and deliver, using all possible legal measures, within twelve (12) months following the signing of the MOA-AD, a plebiscite covering the areas as enumerated in the list and depicted in the map as Category A attached herein (the “Annex”). The Annex constitutes an integral part of this framework agreement. Toward this end, the Parties shall endeavour to complete the negotiations and resolve all outstanding issues on the Comprehensive Compact within fifteen (15) months from the signing of the MOA-AD.

The areas covered by Category B are reflected on a map and list attached herein as agreed to by the Parties. Category B (the “Special Intervention Areas”) refers to conflict affected areas outside the BJE which shall be the subject of special socio-economic and cultural affirmative action implemented by the Central Government pending the conduct of a plebiscite not earlier than twenty-five (25) years from the signing of the Comprehensive Compact to determine the question of their accession to the BJE. The areas reflected are subject to further negotiations by the Parties. The Annex constitutes an integral part of this framework agreement.

Internal Waters:

The BJE shall have jurisdiction over the management, conservation, development, protection, utilization and disposition of all natural resources, living and non-living, within its internal waters extending fifteen (15) kilometers from the coastline of the BJE area.

Territorial Waters:
(1) The territorial waters of the BJE shall stretch beyond the BJE internal waters up to the Republic of the Philippines (RP) baselines south east and south west of mainland Mindanao. Beyond the fifteen (15) kilometers internal waters, the Central Government and the BJE shall exercise joint jurisdiction, authority and management over areas and all natural resources, living and non-living contained therein. The details of such management of the Territorial Waters shall be provided in an agreement to be entered into by the Parties.

(2) The boundaries of the territorial waters shall stretch beyond the 15-km. BJE internal waters up to the Central Government’s baselines under existing laws. In the southern and eastern part of the BJE, it shall be demarcated by a line drawn from the Maguling Point, Palimbang, Province of Sultan Kudarat up to the straight baselines of the Philippines. On the northwestern part, it shall be demarcated by a line drawn from Little Sta. Cruz Island, Zamboanga City, up to Naris Point, Bataraza, Palawan. On the western part of Palawan, it shall be demarcated by a line drawn from the boundary of Bataraza and Rizal up to the straight baselines of the Philippines.

The final demarcation shall be determined by a joint technical body composed of duly-designated representatives of both Parties, in coordination with the appropriate Central Government agency in accordance with the above guidelines.

Sharing of Minerals on Territorial Waters:
Consistent with paragraphs 5 and 6 of the provisions on Resources, all potential sources of energy, petroleum in situ, hydrocarbon, natural gas and other minerals, including deposits or fields found within the territorial waters, shall be shared between the Central Government and the BJE in favor of the latter through production sharing agreement or economic cooperation agreement.

Activities Allowed on Territorial Waters:
(1) The Parties shall have authority to carry out the following activities within the territorial waters:

(a) Exploration and utilization of the natural resources, whether living or non-living, within the territorial waters;
(b) Establishment and use of artificial islands, installations and structures;
(c) Marine scientific research;
(d) Protection and the preservation of the marine environment;
(e) Conservation of living resources;
(f) Regulation of shipping and fishing activities;
(g) Enforcement of police and safety measures, including interdiction of the entry and use of the waters by criminal elements and hot pursuit of suspected criminal elements;
(h) Regulation and control of contraband and illegal entry of prohibited materials and substances, including smuggling; and
(i) Such other measures as the Parties may otherwise mutually agree.

(2) Activities relating to exploration and utilization of non-living resources, as well as paragraphs (c) and (d) of the Authorized Activities will be carried out on a joint basis agreed by the Parties which may be in the form of production sharing agreements or joint development pacts.

Establishment of a Joint Commission:
(1) The Parties shall establish a Joint Commission, which shall elaborate the modalities for the implementation and the carrying out of the Authorized Activities and the measures adopted in cases of allegation of breach, and carry out any other functions which may be assigned to it by the Parties for the purpose of implementing the joint management of resources.

(2) The Joint Commission shall consist of one representative from each Party, who are assisted by advisers as may be needed. The conclusions of the Joint Commission shall be adopted by consensus and shall only be recommendatory in nature. Only when the conclusions of the Joint Commission are adopted by the Parties do they become binding on the Parties.

Demarcation and Status of Territorial Waters:
The demarcation and status of the BJE territorial waters shall be finally determined together with the demarcation and final status of Category B territory of the BJE.
From and after entrenchment of compact rights over the Bangsamoro homeland and the territorial jurisdictions for associative governance shall likewise embrace those under proclamation for agricultural and human settlements intended for the Bangsamoro people, all alienable and disposable lands, pasture lands, timberlands together with all existing civil and military reservations, parks, old growth or natural forests declared as forest reserves, watersheds, mangroves, fishponds, wetlands, marshes, inland bodies of water; and all bays, straits and channels found within the BJE.

All territorial and geographic areas in Mindanao and its adjacent islands including Palawan, and the Sulu archipelago that have been declared recognized, and/or delineated as ancestral domain and ancestral land of the Bangsamoro people as their geographic areas, inclusive of settlements and reservations, may be formed or constituted into political subdivisions of the Bangsamoro territorial jurisdictions subject to the principles of equality of peoples and mutual respect and to the protection of civil, political, economic, and cultural rights in their respective jurisdictions.

For purposes of territorial delimitation, the Parties have agreed to the joint determination of geographic areas encompassed within the territorial borders of the Bangsamoro homeland and territory based on the technical maps and data submitted by both sides as provided above.

RESOURCES

The BJE is empowered with authority and responsibility for the land use, development, conservation and disposition of the natural resources within the homeland. Upon entrenchment of the BJE, the land tenure and use of such resources and wealth must reinforce their economic self-sufficiency. Among the purposes or measures to make progress more rapid are:

Entry into joint development, utilization, and exploitation of natural resources designed as commons or shared resources, which is tied up to the full setting of appropriate institution, particularly affecting strategic minerals;

Stimulation of local economy by a range of mechanism, in particular the need to address unemployment and improvement of living conditions for the population in the BJE;

Intensification of measures needed to uproot the cause of poverty in the BJE through responsible harnessing and development of its natural resources; and
Undertaking program review of public services, industrial or trade-related and agrarian-related issues in situations of different sectors of the society in the BJE, which acquire communal character deriving from the special nature of their industry.

The Bangsamoro People through their appropriate juridical entity shall, among others, exercise power or authority over the natural resources within its territorial jurisdiction:

To explore, exploit, use or utilize and develop their ancestral domain and ancestral lands within their territorial jurisdiction, inclusive of their right of occupation, possession, conservation, and exploitation of all natural resources found therein;
To conserve and protect the human and natural environment for their sustainable and beneficial enjoyment and their posterity;

To utilize, develop, and exploit its natural resources found in their ancestral domain or enter into a joint development, utilization, and exploitation of natural resources, specifically on strategic minerals, designed as commons or shared resources, which is tied up to the final setting of appropriate institution;

To revoke or grant forest concessions, timber license, contracts or agreements in the utilization and exploitation of natural resources designated as commons or shared resources, mechanisms for economic cooperation with respect to strategic minerals, falling within the territorial jurisdiction of the BJE;

To enact agrarian laws and programs suitable to the special circumstances of the Bangsamoro people prevailing in their ancestral lands within the established territorial boundaries of the Bangsamoro homeland and ancestral territory within the competence of the BJE; and

To use such natural resources and wealth to reinforce their economic self-sufficiency.

The BJE, and the Central Government agree on wealth-sharing based on a mutually agreed percentage ratio in favor of the BJE through an economic cooperation agreement or arrangement over the income and revenues that are derived from the exploration, exploitation, use and development of any resources for the benefit of the Bangsamoro people.

The BJE is free to enter into any economic cooperation and trade relations with foreign countries: provided, however, that such relationships and understandings do not include aggression against the Government of the Republic of the Philippines; provided, further that it shall remain the duty and obligation of the Central Government to take charge of external defense. Without prejudice to the right of the Bangsamoro juridical entity to enter into agreement and environmental cooperation with any friendly country affecting its jurisdiction, it shall include:

The option to establish and open Bangsamoro trade missions in foreign countries with which it has economic cooperation agreements; and

The elements bearing in mind the mutual benefits derived from Philippine archipelagic status and security.

And, in furtherance thereto, the Central Government shall take necessary steps to ensure the BJE’s participation in international meetings and events, e.g. ASEAN meetings and other specialized agencies of the United Nations. This shall entitle the BJE’s participation in Philippine official missions and delegations that are engaged in the negotiation of border agreements or protocols for environmental protection, equitable sharing of incomes and revenues, in the areas of sea, seabed and inland seas or bodies of water adjacent to or between islands forming part of the ancestral domain, in addition to those of fishing rights.

Jurisdiction and control over, and the right of exploring for, exploiting, producing and obtaining all potential sources of energy, petroleum, in situ, fossil fuel, mineral oil and natural gas, whether onshore or offshore, is vested in the BJE as the party having control within its territorial jurisdiction, provided that in times of national emergency, when public interest so requires, the Central Government may, during the emergency, for a fixed period and under reasonable terms as may be agreed by both Parties, temporarily assume or direct the operations of such strategic resources.

The BJE take or profit split from total production shall be shared with the Central Government on a percentage ratio of 75:25 in favor of the BJE. All royalties, bonuses, taxes, charges, custom duties or imposts on natural resources and mineral resources shall be shared by the Parties on a percentage ratio of 75:25 in favor of the BJE.

The legitimate grievances of the Bangsamoro people arising from any unjust dispossession of their territorial and proprietary rights, customary land tenures, or their marginalization shall be acknowledged. Whenever restoration is no longer possible, the GRP shall take effective measures or adequate reparation collectively beneficial to the Bangsamoro people, in such quality, quantity and status to be determined mutually by both Parties.

All proclamations, issuances, policies, rules and guidelines declaring old growth or natural forests and all watersheds within the BJE as forest reserves shall continue to remain in force until otherwise modified, revised or superseded by subsequent policies, rules and regulations issued by the competent authority under the BJE.
Forest concessions, timber licenses, contracts or agreements, mining concessions, Mineral Production and Sharing Agreements (MPSA), Industrial Forest Management Agreements (IFMA), and other land tenure instruments of any kind or nature whatsoever granted by the Philippine Government including those issued by the present ARMM shall continue to operate from the date of formal entrenchment of the BJE unless otherwise expired, reviewed, modified and/or cancelled by the latter.
The Parties recognize an immediate need to establish a five-member BJE economic-expert mission (the “Mission”) bearing in mind that the functioning of the economy and the operation of institutions involve financial and other resource management as well as parallel or complementary means, by which the Bangsamoro Development Agency (BDA) will manage and administer resources acquired for the above purposes, especially in coordinating strategies and programs for cooperation in all fields.

The Mission acts as a link in the conduct of BJE’s associative parallel relationships and shall cooperate fully with all organizations involved in implementation of the peace settlement. It shall launch a plan and joint international appeal for the reparation and development of the conflict affected areas in Mindanao. Persons appointed thereto must be familiar with the specific economic, political and legal characteristics in the Mindanao-Sulu-Palawan region and must possess recognized competence, integrity, and high moral standing.

Cognizant that the Mission will benefit from international expertise, both the Central Government and the BJE hereby join the Third Party facilitator in inviting international funding institutions or equivalent entities for reconstruction and development to appoint two members and to designate one as the Chairman. The BJE shall designate one member as Co-Chairman. The remaining two members shall each be designated by the Central Government and the BJE.

GOVERNANCE

The recognition and peaceful resolution of the conflict must involve consultations with the Bangsamoro people free of any imposition in order to provide chances of success and open new formulas that permanently respond to the aspirations of the Bangsamoro people.

The ultimate objective of entrenching the Bangsamoro homeland as a territorial space is to secure their identity and posterity, to protect their property rights and resources as well as to establish a system of governance suitable and acceptable to them as a distinct dominant people. The Parties respect the freedom of choice of the indigenous peoples.

The Parties agree to invite a multinational third - party to observe and monitor the actual implementation of the comprehensive compact which will embody the details for the effective enforcement of this Agreement. The participation of the third – party shall not in any way affect the status of the relationship between the Central Government and the BJE.

The relationship between the Central Government and the BJE shall be associative characterized by shared authority and responsibility with a structure of governance based on executive, legislative, judicial and administrative institutions with defined powers and functions in the Comprehensive Compact. A period of transition shall be established in a Comprehensive Compact specifying the relationship between the Central Government and the BJE.

In the context of implementing prior and incremental agreements between the GRP and MILF, it is the joint understanding of the Parties that the term “entrenchment” means, for the purposes of giving effect to this transitory provision, the creation of a process of institution building to exercise shared authority over territory and defined functions of associative character.

The modalities for the governance intended to settle the outstanding negotiated political issues are deferred after the signing of the MOA-AD.
The establishment of institutions for governance in a Comprehensive Compact, together with its modalities during the transition period, shall be fully entrenched and established in the basic law of the BJE. The Parties shall faithfully comply with their commitment to the associative arrangements upon entry into force of the Comprehensive Compact.

The Parties agree that the mechanisms and modalities for the actual implementation of this MOA-AD shall be spelt out in the Comprehensive Compact to mutually take such steps to enable it to occur effectively.

Any provisions of the MOA-AD requiring amendments to the existing legal framework shall come into force upon signing of a Comprehensive Compact and upon effecting the necessary changes to the legal framework with due regard to non derogation of prior agreements and within the stipulated timeframe to be contained in the Comprehensive Compact.

The Parties agree that the BJE shall be empowered to build, develop and maintain its own institutions, inclusive of, civil service, electoral, financial and banking, education, legislation, legal, economic, and police and internal security force, judicial system and correctional institutions, necessary for developing a progressive Bangsamoro society, the details of which shall be discussed in the negotiation of the Comprehensive Compact.

The Parties further agree to undertake activities which will enhance the capacity of the government institutions during the transition through technical assistance, information-sharing and human resource development.

Matters concerning the details of the agreed consensus points on Governance not covered under this Agreement shall be deferred to, and discussed during, the negotiations of the Comprehensive Compact.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned, being the representatives of the Parties hereby affix their signatures.

Done this 5th day of August, 2008 in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
FOR THE GRP:
(SGD) RODOLFO C. GARCIA
Chairman
GRP Peace Negotiating Panel

FOR THE MILF:
(SGD) MOHAGHER IQBAL
Chairman
MILF Peace Negotiating Panel

WITNESSED BY:
(SGD) DATUK OTHMAN BIN ABD RAZAK
Special Adviser to the Prime Minister

IN THE PRESENCE OF:
(SGD) ALBERTO G. ROMULO
Secretary of Foreign Affairs
Republic of the Philippines

(SGD) DATO’ SERI UTAMA DR. RAIS
BIN YATIM
Minister of Foreign Affairs
Malaysia

Initialed by:
Sec. Rodolfo Garcia
Mohagher Iqbal

Sec. Hermogenes Esperon

Witnessed by:
Datuk Othman bin Abd Razak
Dated 27 July 2008

Saturday, August 23, 2008

THE PRESS AND THE CONSTITUTION

On June 20, 2005, a printing press in Project 3, Quezon City, was raided by the National Bureau of Investigation, for reproducing anti-GMA posters which depicted President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo as Medusa in a caricaturized version of the Resident Evil-turned-President Evil film poster. The NBI reportedly confiscated the bulk of the printed material and invited two of the printing press staff for questioning.

On February 25, 2006 – twenty years after the much-celebrated “People’s Power” – the office of the opposition paper Daily Tribune was also raided by members of the Criminal Investigation and Detection Group and copies of the day’s newspaper edition were confiscated. The raid coincided with President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo’s declaration of a state of emergency amid a destabilization attempt on her government. This move drew condemnation from the Philippine Press Institute which called the raid “a return to those dark days of repression” referring to the martial law era.

The foregoing reports represent a slice of what many believe is becoming prevalent in the present administration: the repression of the freedom of expression.


Freedom of Expression

But just what is freedom of expression? What is freedom of the press? What is freedom of speech? What does the constitution guarantee about such freedom?

Freedom of expression is the ability to effectively communicate ideas from one mind to another without the encumbrance of deterrence. It embraces all forms of “cognate rights” to include freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of religion, freedom of petition, freedom of assembly, the right of association, the right to information, and the right not to be detained because of one’s political beliefs and aspirations.

In defining freedom of speech, Justice Wendell Philips characterized that it is “at once the instrument and the guaranty and the bright consummate flower of all liberty”. While speech is one of the cognate rights embraced in a person’s freedom of expression, it encompasses a wider scope because it is through speech – with the use of languages and symbols – that one’s mind and viewpoints are articulated.

However, it must be noted that such freedom is offered only in matters affecting public interest. Matters of private interest – insofar as their invasion is concerned – are unconstitutional.

As members of a democratic society, the importance of the freedom to express must not lose its ground on us. We are the sovereign. We are what make a democracy. We are the participants to the shaping of our lives. It is therefore, required of us as citizens to be watchful and vigilant that this freedom is not trampled upon. We must be given the chance to tell our story, express our opinion and participate in community, even national forums. It is not merely our right but our duty for our voices to be heard.

In the exercise of this freedom, our mouths must not be muzzled, nor our will cowed. Regardless of the fact that our opinions incite conditions of unrest, or create dissatisfaction, or even stir people’s heart and mind to anger and “invite dispute”, they must not be prevented from being aired.

Note, however, that in relation to the freedom of expression, there lies also on the other half of the equation the right to be silent, the right to listen, and the right not be demanded of our willingness to listen if we choose not to.


Freedom from Censorship

The constitution through Article III, Sections 4 and 18 provides for both the preservation of the freedom of speech, expression et al. and the prohibition of punishment in the exercise of such freedom, respectively – thus, reinforcing freedom from previous restraint or censorship and freedom from subsequent punishment.

Censorship is anathema to the democratic principles of freedom of expression, most especially if the free flow of ideas is curtailed by impositions and prior approval of the government. It is unacceptable that a body, headed by a particular head of a board, becomes the bureaucratic guru of the people as far as their political, moral, social, even artistic choices are concerned.

Therefore, a politician’s speech need not be scrutinized prior to delivery, the wide dissemination of ideas cannot be limited, the government motives can be dissected without fear of censure, and regulated public meetings cannot be prohibited.


Freedom from Punishment

But, being free carries with it the burden of responsibility. While liberty is given for an individual to foster bravery in the utterance of his personal convictions and to be shielded from reprisals resulting from his biting criticisms, his freedom to express is not absolute. When he crosses the line that puts the interest of the public in danger, his freedom then becomes subject to the State’s police power. In which case, the ideas he expresses are subjected to three major criteria that will determine his liability, namely: the clear and present danger rule, the dangerous tendency doctrine, and the balance-of-interest test.

Briefly speaking, the libertarian clear and present danger rule denotes that (1) the idea can be traced clearly through a causal connection with substantive evil as a result of an utterance, (2) the time element is imminently and immediately present, (3) and the danger is not only probably but inevitable.

It is therefore wrong to convict a person at the height of an impassioned speech of inciting an uprising, unless it can be proven that the provocative speech produces clear and present danger. Likewise, the probability that political rallies may result in disruption of public order is not reason enough to suppress the freedom of speech and assembly unless there is enough ground to believe that an imminent danger hovers.

The authoritarian dangerous tendency doctrine, on the other hand, by mere utterance of words that tend to create danger that the State seeks to prevent, may hold a person liable for his spoken ideas – even if they are not actualized. This is a seemingly ridiculous and whimsical travesty of freedom, because tendencies do not constitute a crime.

The balance-of-interest test puts the judiciary in the center of power because it is the court that decides to suspend the freedom of expression if they believe that it is the reasonable thing to do. Issues are resolved depending on the peculiar circumstances of the case.


Criticism of Official Conduct

Corollary to the freedom of expression, the people also have the right, without fear of being prosecuted for defamation, to examine, laud, and censure the public and private conduct of people they elected to office – as long as the comments made public are justified and made in good faith.

A question comes to mind in this particular subject. When First Gentleman Mike Arroyo filed libel charges against some 40 journalists, was he justified in saying that he is a private, not a public, citizen? The National Union of Journalists of the Philippines does not seem to think so. The journalists contend that “his statements and conduct are of public or general interest because of the last name he shares with the President. The various causes to which he attaches either his name or his ‘title’ open doors—and purses—that would otherwise be closed to anyone else.“

Nevertheless, a private individual involved in public issues may still be the subject of public comments.

The private lives of public figures are sensitive issues. For instance, a fictionalized embellishment of a person’s biography can be restrained from exhibition as in the case of the Moises Padilla story, but the filming of factual accounts of an event involving actual persons waives the right to privacy as was the case in Juan Ponce Enrile’s objection to the production of a movie depicting the People Power EDSA revolution.

Even members of the judiciary are not exempt from public scrutiny, although it bans comments on pending cases for fear of interference with the administration of justice. Disrespectful language used against members of the Supreme Court merited a contempt charge against a columnist. And separate rulings are made against members of the bar of lawyers in their exercise of freedom of expression.


Art and Obscenity

As part of the exercise of the freedom of expression, the artistic merits of art – particularly film – and literature continue to pose many questions about the power of the State to enforce censorship.

In the past, several films have been banned from being screened locally by virtue of the Movie and Television Review and Classification Board’s own moral standards. Among them were, The Last Temptation of Christ by Martin Scorcese because it was deemed anti-religion; Priest which told of affairs between a priest and a woman and another priest and a man; Schindler’s List because of a humping scene involving a girl; even Meryl Streep’s pubic hairs in The Bridges of Madison County caused a stir. The MTRCB came under raging fire!

But the question that begs answering is this: what really constitutes obscenity? What is pornographic in nature? Whose point of view reigns supreme as far as deciding what merits classification and censorship?

The Miller v. California case laid down a three-fold test of obscenity: (1) will the average person find that the film appeals to lust, (2) does the work depict an explicitly offensive sexual conduct, (3) does the overall work lack serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value? To which, Judge Douglas dissented in simpler terms: until one can precisely define what obscenity is, it is a monstrous thing to send men to jail for violating standards that are not clear to them.

The Bible, which is the holiest of books, contain a whole book – Song of Solomon – that depicts intimate almost Playboy-like narrative between a man and his wife. A particularly graphic passage in the Bible may be considered obscene by purists. It is found in Ezekiel 23:18-21. Referring metaphorically to Israel, it says:

When she carried on her prostitution openly and exposed her nakedness, I turned away from her in disgust, just as I had turned away from her sister. Yet she became more and more promiscuous as she recalled the days of her youth, when she was a prostitute in Egypt. There she lusted after her lovers, whose genitals were like those of donkeys and whose emission was like that of horses. So you longed for the lewdness of your youth, when in Egypt your bosom was caressed and your young breasts fondled.

In this particular sense –art being a personal conviction– censorship presents peculiar ‘dangers’ to constitutionally protected freedom of expression.

Assembly and Petition

Also ensconced in Article III, Section 4 of the Constitution is the “right of people peaceably to assemble and petition the Government for redress of grievances”.

Public assembly is an effective forum for lawful discussion in order to be heard, to exchange views, to filter ideas affecting the common good. Therefore, its practice must not be hindered by a mere technicality such as issuance of permit from government authorities. It must be noted that the issuance of permit is not for the assembly to take place but for the use of public place as the venue of assembly, and that it is only meant to regulate and not prohibit the assembly.

However, it must be considered also that the government authorities may suggest an alternative location if it is warranted that holding an assembly in an applied-for location may pose disruptions to other activities taking place within the vicinity.

Permits are applied for in writing at least five days prior to the scheduled meeting and shall be acted upon within two days. If no action is taken within two days, the permit is deemed granted. If denied, justification of the assembly creating clear and present danger to public order must be presented. Action on application must be communicated to applicant within 24 hours, and appeal lodged to the appropriate court who shall then decide on the merit of the appeal also within 24 hours.

On the other hand, a permit is not required if the assembly is held in (1) a private place, (2) the campus of a government-owned and operated school, (3) a freedom park established in a municipality or city.

What, then, makes a lawful assembly? Primarily, it depends on the purpose for which the assembly is held irrespective of sponsorship. But a decision in the Evangelista v. Earnshaw case which ruled the prohibition of the members of the Communist Party to meet is not yet revoked. Even untoward incidents resulting from assemblies; coarse language by student activists; apprehensions of violence do not make them unlawful.

Moreover, participation in demonstrations as a matter of fighting for survival and being consequently dismissed from work is not lawful.


Right of Association

Man, being a social being, has the right to associate with people of similar persuasions, interests and objectives. Article III, Section 8 provides that “the right of the people, including those employed in the public and private sectors, to form unions, associations or societies for purposes not contrary to law shall not be abridged.”

This right – provided that it is not contrary to the law, i.e. not aimed at overthrowing the government – comes within the confines of the freedom of expression because associations and organizations provide a good platform for expression of views that have effects on public welfare. Membership to an organization lends a louder voice to a cause and is better than being an individual advocate.

Notable is the fact that even government employees are given the right to self-organization, although for them, the right to declare a strike to enforce economic demands remains to be vague.

On the other hand, the right to associate also allows the right not to associate. Persons, who by virtue of their religious affiliation are prohibited from affiliating, may not be forced to join any union – unless it is their choice to forego what their religion dictates.

A particular case of invoking the right not to associate (by not paying his membership dues) drew the ire of the Supreme Court when a lawyer was told in no uncertain terms that his being a lawyer irrevocably makes him a member of the Bar – and is therefore obliged to pay his membership due, whether or not he associates with his fellow lawyers.


Conclusion

Reading stories similar to the ones at the beginning of this summary paper strikes a disturbing chord in the mind. The raid of the printing press and the newspaper office are but small anecdotes of the government’s attempt to silence its critics. There are many more, perhaps, undocumented and unreported cases of freedom of expression being gagged.

As citizens of a free and democratic country, it is therefore our obligation to put to heart the very words of the Constitution that preserves this liberating freedom, as embodied in our Bill of Rights.

Article III, Section 4
No law shall be passed abridging the freedom of speech, of expression, or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble and petition the government for redress of grievances.

DROP BOX



In this blog, I will post all the essays, reflection papers, summary reports, policy paper, and all written works gathered through three years of hard labor inside the walls of Letran.